Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Because working ensures that you're doing something that is useful to someone else.

"Most people want to do something of value."

A universal basic income is kind of this wierd bourgeois selfish projection wrapped in this veneer of being altruistic: To be 'freed to do whatever one prefers' is really saying "I want to do what I want, regardless of whether or not it's socially beneficial".

The wierd thing about free markets is that although one can be selfish and money-grubbing, even the most mendacious and stingy person must do something in the service of another to accrue capital.



> The wierd thing about free markets is that although one can be selfish and money-grubbing, even the most mendacious and stingy person must do something in the service of another to accrue capital.

And the failure mode of that is people ending up doing things in service on someone else that do a net damage to society, while other people do something in service of someone else to undo the work of the first group. Not to mention people stuck in positive feedback loops that waste increasing amount of resources on cancelling each other out. See marketing for a good example.

Just because something is useful to someone, doesn't mean it should be done.


My argument is that people will desire valuable labor because well, we already do. We prefer being valuable to boredom.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: