Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Regulated campaign finance...who writes the rules?

Ideally,

> the people

I think the "people -> government" relationship is broken in the US and I'm not sure whether all the "blood of patriots and tyrants" talk helps or hurts that.



Well, the US is a Republic and not a democracy. Even in the case of a direct democracy, should we have 50.1% deciding for the 100%? If only it were a trivial game it would be an easy answer!

Quoting Jefferson isn't a call to action, but a call to remember those words, the context and the inspiration. It's insightful to remember that Jefferson was the founder of a third-party known as the Democratic-Republicans.

As much as people think the world is different, the difference is really only technologically. Instead of stealing horses, people steal cars. Instead of bootlegging liquor, people run marijuana.

Instead of slave masters, we have human resources.


Quoting Jefferson isn't a call to action

But it sure makes you sound like a man of action!

Two political Sects have arisen within the U.S. the one believing that the executive is the branch of our government which the most needs support; the other that like the analogous branch in the English Government, it is already too strong for the republican parts of the Constitution; and therefore in equivocal cases they incline to the legislative powers: the former of these are called federalists, sometimes aristocrats or monocrats, and sometimes tories, after the corresponding sect in the English Government of exactly the same definition: the latter are stiled republicans, whigs, jacobins, anarchists, disorganizers, etc. these terms are in familiar use with most persons."

- Jefferson in 1798 - you'll note that he was arguing that the republicans of his day were insufficiently democratic, rather than the other way round.

As much as people think the world is different, the difference is really only technologically. Instead of stealing horses, people steal cars. Instead of bootlegging liquor, people run marijuana. Instead of slave masters, we have human resources.

Well, there's a slight qualitative difference in that if you quit your job, HR can't come after you and compel you stay in it. Your creditors may sue you for everything short of the shirt off your back, but you can't be forced into servitude.


I republic is a form of democracy. There is no such thing as a pure democracy, so making that distinction is a little meaningless.


I upvoted you, but while we are nitpicking: "a little meaningless" is quite like saying "a little pregnant" ;-)


Ah ok, I had the slight impression that you didn't want to discuss this and instead just voice your opinion. Confirmed and noted.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: