Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is this stuff actually anything new? It seems like free-speech has been under constant assault as long as such rights have been recognized.

The precise details shift around a bit, but free speech has always been something that has to be actively maintained: formal guarantees aren't—and I think have never been—sufficient. I don't think there's ever been a time when you could just sit back and enjoy it...

[The reason I ask is because the article seems to written to give the impression that is some sort of worrying new development...]



These assaults are absolutely not new, but from my limited vantage point, previous assaults have mostly revolved around vulgarity. The new wave seems to revolve around "hate", which is worrisome given how subjective and slippery the term is. The described tale of "Zombie Muhammed" is a perfect example: a light-hearted joke to one person is a vicious act of "hate" to another.

Protecting people's feelings should not be the role of the state.


I don't think that category is that new either, though it's hard to say if it's increasing in frequency. One very traditional category is desecration of cherished symbols: blasphemy laws are one very old example (still extant in some of Europe), and the U.S. has had recurring debates over whether flag burning should be outlawed, which it actually was for a time (basically the patriotic American's version of calling for Koran-burning to be outlawed).

I do think it's true that, at least since the 1960s or so, the U.S. has supported a basically unlimited range of political opinion (excluding the flag-burning issue). Perhaps something of a historical anomaly, though, since even in the U.S. that was generally not true earlier: between various sedition acts, laws suppressing communist and anarchist publications, laws suppressing anti-segregationist speech, etc., there have been significant restrictions on "fringe" speech through much of US history.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: