Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I'm able to detect more sophisticated changes in the field

The magnet implant is probably way more sensitive vs this binary device, since it's pressing your sensory receptors in your fingers; they can also sense temperature and position changes.



Okay, this might have been an overstatement. I assumed that you can't feel static magnetic field, only changing one. Can anyone with a magnet implant comment?


Presumably, a magnet implant would allow you to feel a static magnetic field by moving your hand around, since that would, from your finger's point of view, turn it into a changing magnetic field.


You can feel both. For me static fields are a very strange feeling which is not very comfortable. Having only one small magnet (the second generation ones from Steve Haworth) I have to concentrate to feel a low static magnetic field.

Changing ones are more obvious and way more comfy. I think this is because a static one pulls or pushes the magnet all the time while changing ones let the magnet "vibrate" (from pulling and pushing all the time).


Does the magnet even have to be implanted? I'd think that you could just stick it to your finger and get the same results without resorting to surgery. Perhaps just use one of those little rubber fingertips that administrative assistants use while filing?


This is my response to a previous comment in here, copy and pasted to you:

As someone with the actual implant, I'd say no.

Think of it this way, people have been wearing magnetic body jewelry as an alternative to piercings for decades. Sensing magnetic fields has never been associated with magnetic jewelry.

The same way that holding a buckyball between two fingers close to a fan doesn't really create an unusual or striking response, comparatively.

There's something unique about the implant that can't be replicated in other ways. I mean, I haven't tried this external device, but the above is my response to questions about magnetic rings, nail polish, earrings, etc.


What if it were glued on? The idea is cool, but there's no way I would want something surgically implanted like that. It's just better to be able to remove it when needed.


I say give it a try. It will be an experience, even if it's not the same experience.

I'd say a large part of the difference is mental. With an implant, your body internalizes the sensations, they're part of your body, your "one"-ness. With external sources, you may still feel the sensations, but they're not yours. Your body doesn't feel the fields, it feels an object that feels the fields.

It's hard to explain, and that's the best I got.


Are you sure about that? Haven't you ever felt your car as an extension of yourself while driving or anything like that?


I did that once. Taped a strong magnet to my finger. I could feel strong magnetic fields, but not for long as I had to keep it really tight. A neat experience though, no surgery required


It's not binary - look at the argument to buzzer() in the code. It's clearly programmed to vibrate the buzzer more when a stronger magnetic field is detected.


I agree. How do you think that could be circumvented w/o an implant? Electrodes might work but who wants to do that….




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: