Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This. The names of many tribes is simply "the people" in their language. You can easily read into it that those humans not that are not members of their tribe are not people. http://www.native-languages.org/original.htm


We invented huge anonymous cities where either tight surveillance or gang wars flourish, extermination camps, total war and many other wonders. Let's explain to any tribe that we, 'people', painfully devised and realized ways to massively and indiscriminately kill very remote civilians using dedicated complex machinery (ICBMs), then discuss about who is 'people' for who.

Comparing the 'costs' of nearly-constant but limited tribal violence to our own 'civilized' violence isn't easy.


They are the exact same thing. We have just transplanted those tribal aspects to our modern world, but we still are the same people.


Indeed. Therefore the "outsiders aren't real people" stance isn't specific to tribal life.

Upon reading (above) "Tribal politics are brutal" and "Life was way harder" one may think about the way we wage war, establish the rat race in huge cities, try hard to control everything everywhere to the point of practically barring anyone to opt out... "brutal"? "harder"? Doubt so.


> Therefore the "outsiders aren't real people" stance isn't specific to tribal life.

Nobody said it is.


Please read "armenarmen" comment, above: "those humans not that are not members of their tribe are not people". Albeit difficult to grok, it seems pretty clear to me.


armenarmen said that happens in tribal life; but not that it was unique/specific to tribal life.


That's not my understanding, as he answered "This." to a post containing "Tribal politics are brutal, and any ancient community would have a very strong sense of identity, and about who belonged and who didn't. Life was way harder...".





Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: